Which is best for carpet cleaning, steam cleaner or carpet cleaner?

Carpets should be regularly vacuumed, but a deep clean is necessary for removing ingrained dirt. This can be done by a carpet cleaner or a steam cleaner, but which is best? Cleaning experts say that there are pros and cons for each type of cleaner.

Cleaning professional Polya Petrova explains that steam cleaners use high-temperature steam that loosens dirt without requiring detergent. Carpet cleaners spray a cleaning solution mixture that penetrates well into the carpet pile. After using either cleaner, a vacuum should be used to remove loose dirt.

Steam cleaners work well on carpet tiles and short pile carpets, but are not as effective on deep pile carpets. Floorcare expert at Ideal Home Lauren Bradbury says carpet cleaners are better than steam cleaners because they push the cleaning solution deep into the pile.

"Steam cleaning is excellent for sanitising and surface-level dirt – especially on hard floors like tile, vinyl, or laminate – but it doesn’t penetrate carpet fibres as effectively."

Steam cleaners are easier to use as they are typically lighter, quicker to get ready and need no detergents. Carpet cleaners are bulkier and more complex to use, requiring pre-treatment, filling tanks and drying time. However, manufacturers are developing carpet cleaners that are lighter and easier to use. 

If a carpet is heavily stained and worn, is probably time for a new one. Contact a local carpet retailer in Chester or North Wales and ask to see their range of stain-resistant carpets.